Paris, France – Global music icon Beyoncé is facing significant backlash over a t-shirt worn during a performance in Paris as part of her “Cowboy Carter” tour. The garment, displayed during a Juneteenth show, has ignited a firestorm of criticism, particularly from Native American advocates, who contend its text promotes harmful and historically inaccurate narratives.
Shirt Text and Imagery Detailed
The t-shirt in question prominently featured images of Buffalo Soldiers, the historic African-American regiments formed after the Civil War. However, the controversy centers on text printed on the back of the shirt. This text referred to the soldiers’ “antagonists” using highly charged language, specifically listing them as “the enemies of peace, order and settlement: warring Indians, bandits, cattle thieves, murderous gunmen, bootleggers, trespassers, and Mexican revolutionaries.”
Images and videos of the performance and the shirt are available on Beyoncé’s official website, allowing the public to view the garment and its controversial wording.
Backlash from Native American Advocates
Immediately following the performance, a wave of criticism emerged on social media platforms. Native influencers, performers, and academics were among the most vocal critics, expressing profound concern and condemnation regarding the shirt’s message.
They have explicitly labeled the language used on the shirt as anti-Indigenous, arguing that defining Native Americans, specifically referred to as “warring Indians” in the text, as inherent “enemies of peace, order and settlement” perpetuates harmful stereotypes that have historically been used to justify violence and dispossession against Indigenous peoples.
Furthermore, critics have questioned the broader context of using Western symbolism within the “Cowboy Carter” era, particularly in a way that appears to endorse or uncritically present historical narratives that marginalize or demonize Native communities. Concerns were raised that such usage could inadvertently promote American nationalism built upon exclusionary or harmful historical interpretations.
Context of the Performance
The performance took place during a Juneteenth celebration in Paris. Juneteenth commemorates the emancipation of enslaved African Americans and is a date of significant cultural and historical importance. The inclusion of imagery related to the Buffalo Soldiers, many of whom were former slaves, aligns with themes of Black history and empowerment often explored in Beyoncé’s work, including her recent album, “Cowboy Carter,” which delves into the roots and influence of Black artists in country and Western music.
However, critics argue that the specific historical narrative presented on the shirt overshadows this context and fails to acknowledge the complex and often violent role Buffalo Soldiers played in conflicts with Native Americans during the westward expansion of the United States.
Response Status and Historical Note
As of the time of this article’s publication, a publicist for Beyoncé had not responded to requests for comment regarding the controversy or the meaning and intent behind the t-shirt’s text.
The Buffalo Soldiers National Museum in Houston, Texas, is noted as housing artifacts related to the Buffalo Soldiers, preserving their history and contributions. While the museum itself is not involved in the current controversy, it serves as a repository for the historical record of the regiments featured on the garment.
The incident highlights the sensitive nature of historical representation in popular culture and the potential for garments and symbols to provoke significant debate and criticism when they intersect with complex and painful historical narratives, particularly those involving marginalized communities.
